“My child loves writing stories at home, so why are their marks so ordinary?” I hear that a lot. The honest answer is that a story written for fun and a story written for an examiner are two different things. The second one can be taught.
Creative writing is the part of the 11+ that worries parents most, because it feels like talent. It isn’t, mostly. Examiners reward a short list of things they can see on the page, and a child who knows that list writes calmly and finishes on time.
Schools word it differently, but the official guidance says the same things. ISEB’s 11+ Common Entrance specification gives marks for content, purpose, style and organisation (a story with a beginning, middle and end), and for the quality and range of language. Exeter School’s guidance for parents asks children to express what they think, feel or imagine, put ideas in a sensible order, use a good range of words, and write accurately.
Notice what is missing. Nobody asks for a twist ending, a dragon or a page of long words. They want a clear, complete piece that sounds like a real person wrote it.
When I mark a practice piece, I mark it out of 30 so a child can see exactly where the marks came from. It is three sets of five, 2 marks each.
Sight, sound, smell, touch and taste, woven into the writing rather than listed. Smell is the one children forget, and it is often the most powerful.
Simile, metaphor, personification, alliteration and onomatopoeia. One at a time, used with control. Five devices in one sentence reads like a list, not a story.
Conjunctions, connectives, adverbs, paragraphing and personal response: the character’s own thoughts and feelings running through the piece.
Then I take off up to 5 marks for spelling, punctuation and grammar. That matches how schools think too: in 11+ Common Entrance, a school can add up to 10 extra marks just for spelling, sentences and punctuation, so accuracy is scored separately from ideas.
Here is a title I might set: The Empty Station. This is the kind of opening I see when a child writes without a plan:
“I got to the station. It was empty and scary. I was very scared. Then I heard a noise and I went to see what it was.”
Sight only, no devices, “scared” told twice, and every sentence starts the same way.
“The station clock ticked above an empty platform. Rain hissed on the tracks, and the air smelt of wet iron. My fingers tightened around the strap of my bag. Somewhere in the dark, a door creaked open.”
Sight, sound, smell and touch. Personification and onomatopoeia. Fear shown, not told.
The second version is not cleverer. It uses the same simple words a ten-year-old knows. The difference is that the child stopped and asked: what can I hear, what can I smell, what are my hands doing?
“Write what a camera would see. A camera can’t film ‘scared’.”
It can film trembling hands, a held breath, eyes flicking to the door. That one rule, show don’t tell, lifts more 11+ stories than anything else I teach.
Exeter School’s guidance says it plainly: spend time planning, and there is space on the paper for it. Common Entrance builds 5 minutes of reading and planning into its 45. I teach a five-minute plan, and children use it for every practice piece until it is automatic.
Is it a story, a description, a letter? What mood fits? A description needs no plot: pick four or five things in the scene and zoom in on each one.
Opening hook, build-up, problem, climax, ending. One or two characters and a short time frame. A whole afternoon is plenty; a whole summer holiday is too much.
Jot one word for each: clock, rain, wet iron, cold strap, metal taste. Now the description is half written.
One simile, one metaphor, one short sentence for drama, one line of speech, one show-don’t-tell moment. Tick them off as they go in.
Full stops and capitals, speech marks, and a new paragraph for each new time, place or person.
The children who score highest are not always the most imaginative. They are the ones who plan.
A simple story with a clear shape beats a brilliant idea that runs out of time halfway through the problem.
Some children learn one story and bend every title to fit it. Examiners notice. In Common Entrance, marks go to how well the writing suits the task, so a story that ignores the title loses marks, however polished it is.
“Ameliorate” in a story about a lost puppy sounds odd. Ambitious words used correctly are great; long words used wrongly cost marks. Exeter School says children should not avoid adventurous words just in case of a spelling slip, which is good advice.
Two smaller ones: opening with “One day” or “My name is”, and no paragraphs at all. Both are easy to fix in a week.
You don’t need a story every night. Short, focused practice works better, and it keeps writing enjoyable.
Start in Year 5, and keep it small.
Two short sessions a week for a year will do far more than a panic of daily stories in the month before the test.
Writing sits alongside comprehension in most school English papers, so it pays to practise both. The free 11+ guide covers the English skills these papers share, and the school finder shows how entry works at each school. If your child is also sitting a grammar school test with a writing stage, my guide to the Sutton SET explains how that works.
No. ISEB’s framework says the Pre-Test English test covers reading comprehension and grammar (vocabulary, punctuation, grammar and spelling). There is no extended writing task. Many schools that use the Pre-Test set their own writing task later, so check each school.
It depends on the school. The 11+ Common Entrance Composition paper is 45 minutes, including 5 minutes for reading and planning. Exeter School, for example, asks candidates to spend 30 minutes on its writing section. Always read each school’s own guidance.
Exeter School asks for about one side of A4 in 30 minutes, which is a sensible guide for most 11+ tasks. A complete, well-planned piece of that length is worth more than three unfinished pages.
Yes. In 11+ Common Entrance, schools can add up to 5 marks for spelling and 5 for sentence structure and punctuation, on top of the 25 for the writing itself. Exeter School says it looks for secure spelling of common words, and children should not avoid adventurous words for fear of misspelling them.
Usually not. Exeter School, for example, says the picture is there to spark ideas, and candidates can add their own details as long as they answer the question.
In 11+ Common Entrance the planning sheet is not sent to the senior school, so it is for the child’s benefit only. That is exactly why it is worth five minutes.
I prepare children 1:1 online for 11+, 13+ and 16+ entry to the UK’s leading independent and grammar schools. Tell me about your child and the schools you are considering, and I will tell you honestly what the preparation should look like.
Enquire About LessonsSources: ISEB: Common Entrance English at 11+, 13+ and CASE · ISEB: CE English specification, 11+ and 13+ (PDF) · ISEB Pre-Tests Framework 2026-27 (PDF) · Exeter School: 11+ and 12+ English entrance examination guidance (PDF). Details change from year to year, so always check the official websites before you apply.