“Should we go for grammar, independent, or both?” Parents usually ask me this in Year 4 or Year 5, often after a playground conversation that left them more confused than before. It is a fair question. The two routes look alike from the outside, because both have an 11+ test, but they work very differently once you start applying.
Here is how I explain it, with the official dates and rules, and the questions I would ask before deciding.
A state school that selects pupils by academic ability, with a test to get in. It can be run by the council, a foundation or an academy trust.
Passing the test makes your child eligible. The place itself depends on the school’s admission criteria, which often include distance from home.
Also called a private school. It charges fees instead of being funded by the government and does not have to follow the national curriculum. Since 1 January 2025, VAT at 20% applies to private school fees.
Every school runs its own admissions, so each one can look at the whole child: tests, interview, reference.
| Question | Grammar school | Independent school |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays? | Free: state-funded | Fees, plus VAT since January 2025. Ask each school about bursaries |
| Who sets the test? | The council or a group of schools, e.g. the Kent Test, the Buckinghamshire transfer test or the Sutton SET | The school, a group like the London 11+ Consortium, or ISEB |
| How do I apply? | Register for the test, then name the school on your council’s secondary form | Register directly with each school |
| Does a pass guarantee a place? | No. Places go by the school’s admission criteria | The school decides, using its own assessment |
| Curriculum | Depends on how it is run: council-run schools follow the national curriculum, academies have more freedom | Does not have to follow the national curriculum |
Choose the school, not the label.
There are brilliant grammar schools and brilliant independent schools, and some of each that would not suit your child at all. Visit, watch how the children talk to each other, and ask yourself whether your child would be happy there on a wet Tuesday in February.
Yes, and many families do. The two systems run side by side, and a council place does not stop you accepting an independent one. The trick is the calendar, because the grammar route starts much earlier than parents expect. Here is how the year ran for children starting Year 7 in September 2027, using Kent as the example:
If your child is in Year 5 now, expect the same pattern next year. Medway and Bexley run their own tests, separate from the Kent Test, and other areas have their own dates, so check your own council’s page.
This is where I can help most, because the tests reward slightly different things.
In my experience, grammar tests are often multiple choice and tight on time. Verbal reasoning is often a big part. When I teach analogies, I ask the child to say the link as a sentence. Puppy is to dog as kitten is to ? becomes “a puppy is a baby dog”, so the answer must be “a baby cat”: kitten is to cat. Same sentence, applied exactly. My guide to verbal reasoning question types has more.
Independent schools often add a writing task and an interview. For creative writing I mark out of 30 with my Triple Five: the five senses, five literary devices, and CCAPP (conjunctions, connectives, adverbs, paragraphing, a personal response), two marks each, minus up to five for spelling, punctuation and grammar. A child who writes “The wind hissed through the broken window, cold as a key on my neck” has already picked up sound, touch, personification and a simile in one line. More in 11+ creative writing.
Preparing for both is less work than it sounds.
Strong arithmetic, a wide vocabulary and a reading habit sit underneath every one of these tests. Build those first, then spend the last few months on the formats your child will actually sit.
Read the admission criteria for each grammar school. A pass does not help if you live outside the area the school takes from. Kent says its grammar schools are for about the top 25% of the ability range.
Work out the full cost through to Year 11 or Year 13, with VAT. Ask each school about bursaries early, and when you need to apply for one.
Go in with the same questions for each: class sizes, homework, clubs, how they support a child who finds something hard.
Name the schools in true order of preference. Gov.uk says listing only one school will not raise your chances there.
It closes in the summer of Year 5, months before most independent registrations. Put it in the diary now.
Families going mostly independent sometimes skip it. If the independent offer doesn’t come, you want a good state school already on the list.
Whichever way you lean, start with the school pages for the places you are looking at: our school guides list the test each school uses. And if you are in Year 5 now, my Year 5 plan sets out what to do term by term.
Yes. Grammar schools are state schools, so there are no fees. They select pupils by academic ability, with a test to get in (gov.uk).
No. Kent, for example, says being assessed suitable does not guarantee a place: oversubscribed schools rank applicants by their admission criteria, and you must name the school on your council application.
31 October in Year 6, through your local council. Offers are sent on 1 March, or the next working day if it falls at a weekend (gov.uk).
No. Gov.uk says you apply directly to a private school. Each school sets its own registration deadline and tests.
Yes. Since 1 January 2025, education and boarding services provided by private schools for a charge are subject to VAT at 20% (HMRC).
The two systems are separate, so you can apply to both. Accept your council offer by the deadline in the offer letter, or it may be withdrawn, and check each independent school’s own acceptance date.
I prepare children 1:1 online for 11+, 13+ and 16+ entry to the UK’s leading independent and grammar schools. Tell me about your child and the schools you are considering, and I will tell you honestly what the preparation should look like.
Enquire About LessonsSources: Gov.uk: Types of school (grammar schools) · Gov.uk: Types of school (private schools) · Gov.uk: School admissions, how to apply · Gov.uk: School admissions, admission criteria · HMRC: VAT on private school fees · Kent County Council: Register for the Kent Test · Kent County Council: Apply for a Kent grammar school place · Kent County Council: Secondary school places. Details change from year to year, so always check the official websites before you apply.